Why did I take so long to call for help when Abel and Sunny were right there, behind that upstairs window?
I still ask myself that. Abel is a grown man now. Sunny’s grown too. They both got out of that house, and Vernon lived. So I know how it ended, at least the part that fits in an official report. I still don’t know what Moses understood that I didn’t.
I’m Bev Loomis. I was sixty-seven that fall, living alone on twelve acres in the Missouri Ozarks. My husband, Lyman, had been gone three winters. I had two old cats, apple trees, and more quiet than I knew what to do with.
Vernon Crisp lived a quarter mile down our gravel road. He was seventy, maybe a little older. I never asked. He didn’t wave much, and after Lyman died he didn’t bring food or even a card. I took that personally at the time. I guess I wanted everybody to show grief in the same way I did.
His daughter was overseas with the Army, and she’d left Abel, seven, and Sunny, four, with him. Sometimes I saw them playing near his porch. I’d wave. Abel waved back. Sunny usually hid behind him.
I told myself Vernon had things under control. That was easy to say from my own porch.
It was a warm September morning when I found the donkey. I was checking the fence where the ground dips by Vernon’s barn, and I heard a little scrape, scrape, scrape. I thought a branch was dragging against the boards.
The donkey was tied behind the barn with a short rusty chain. Gray, white nose, ribs showing. His water bucket was tipped over and dry inside. His hooves had grown so long they curled up at the ends. I remember thinking his feet looked like he was wearing old slippers.
He couldn’t get to the shade.
When I stepped closer, he made a soft sound. Not a bray. More like he was asking something.
I went home and cried, which still embarrasses me a little. Then I filled a bucket with water and took a bag of apples from Lyman’s trees. I had no business crossing Vernon’s fence. I knew that. I went anyway.
The donkey drank so fast he bumped the bucket against the post. Then I gave him an apple. He ate it carefully, lips warm against my fingers. I called him Moses, though I don’t know why. The name just came out.
The next morning, he was waiting.
I started going before daylight because I didn’t want Vernon to see me. One bucket of water, three or four apples. I told myself I was only doing it until I could figure out what else to do. I kept telling myself that.
Moses began making that little sound as soon as he saw me. After about a week, his ribs weren’t quite so sharp. His eyes looked brighter. I know that sounds small. It didn’t feel small to me.
The kids were around more than I expected. One morning, Sunny came to the fence while I was pouring water.
“Is that donkey yours?” she asked.
“No, honey.”
“Does Grandpa know you’re here?”
I looked toward the house. “I don’t think so.”
She nodded, like that was the answer she expected. Then she said, “He gets mad when Moses makes noise.”
I should have asked what she meant. I should have asked more than that. Instead I said, “You stay on your side of the fence, okay?”
She went back toward the porch. I carried the empty bucket home and thought about her words all morning.
A few days later, I saw Abel in the yard with a piece of bread. He had one hand on the porch rail and was looking toward the barn.
“Does Moses get fed?” I asked.
Abel shrugged. “Grandpa says he does.”
That was all. I could have called the sheriff then. I could have called the county animal office, though I didn’t know the number. I could have knocked on Vernon’s door and said what I’d seen.
Instead I brought more apples the next morning.
That part is mine to own.
I had a little red notebook in the kitchen where I wrote down the feed-store number, a vet’s name, and the days I’d gone to Moses. I’m not sure why I wrote the days down. Maybe I wanted proof for myself that I wasn’t imagining how bad it was. Maybe I was trying to make a plan without having to start a fight.
On the thirty-first morning, Vernon caught me.
I heard the screen door slam behind the barn. I turned around with the bucket in one hand and the apples in the other. Vernon stood there in his boots and undershirt with a shotgun pointed at my chest.
The metal bucket handle had dug into my fingers. I remember that, oddly enough.
“What are you doing on my land?” he said.
“Vernon, he’s starving. His bucket’s been empty.”
“He’s my animal.”
“He needs water.”
“I said he’s mine.”
His face was red, and his voice was shaking a little. Not just anger, I thought. Something else too, though I didn’t know what.
“You think you’re better than me?” he said. “You and Lyman, always playing good neighbors.”
“I never thought that.”
“Touch my animal again, old woman, and I’ll bury you both.”
Abel and Sunny were on the porch behind him. Sunny was crying. Abel had one hand around her shoulder, and he was watching the gun, not me.
That was when I stopped arguing. I didn’t think I was brave. I thought about the kids, and I thought about what might happen if Vernon got arrested. I put the bucket down.
“Okay,” I said.
Vernon kept the gun aimed at me while I backed through the fence. I left the apples beside the post. I didn’t look back until I was halfway home.
I didn’t call the sheriff that day. I didn’t call anyone. I was scared, and I made myself believe I was protecting the children by staying quiet. Really, I was scared of Vernon. Both things can be true.
That night I kept hearing the screen door slam. I got up twice to check the back lock. The cats followed me around, mad because I wouldn’t let them sleep.
At some point I opened the red notebook. I looked at the vet’s number. I even picked up the phone. Then I set it down.
I can tell you exactly what time I woke up because the clock by my bed said 2:07.
A donkey was braying outside my bedroom window. Not once. Over and over. Loud enough that both cats scrambled under the bed.
I grabbed my flashlight and went to the porch in my nightgown. Moses was standing in the yard. A broken length of chain hung from his neck, and his sides were working hard.
“Moses,” I said.
He turned toward Vernon’s place and ran. A few yards down the road he stopped, looked back at me, and brayed again.
I put on my boots without changing. Then I called 911 as I ran. I told the woman there was a fire at Vernon Crisp’s house and children inside. I didn’t know if they were still inside, but I’d seen them earlier. She asked for the address. I gave her the gravel road and the mailbox number, and I kept moving.
The fire showed before I reached the bend. Smoke was coming from under the eaves, and the downstairs windows had an orange glow. Vernon’s truck sat in the driveway with its lights off.
Nobody was outside.
I heard the dispatcher in my ear, asking if I could see anyone. Then I saw two small hands pressed to an upstairs window.
“Stay there!” I shouted, which was a useless thing to say through glass. “I see you!”
Moses stopped beside me, chain dragging on the road. I told the dispatcher where the children were. My voice got loud. I’m sure I sounded foolish, but I kept repeating the window, upstairs, the window facing the road.
I tried the front door. The heat pushed me back before I got close enough to touch the handle. I couldn’t go in. I knew that, but I tried again anyway, and a man’s voice on the phone told me to get back.
The first fire truck turned in so fast its tires kicked gravel against my legs. A firefighter came around with a ladder. I pointed up and shouted, “Two kids. Two kids in that window.”
He climbed. I stayed below, holding the ladder while another firefighter came up behind him. The window opened. Abel was crying, but he was moving. Sunny was tucked against his side.
“Give me Sunny,” the firefighter called.
Abel passed her through. The firefighter brought her down first, then went back for Abel. I held Sunny against me. Her pajama top smelled like smoke, and she was shaking so hard her teeth tapped together.
“Is Abel coming?” she asked.
“He’s coming,” I said. “He’s right there.”
He came down with the firefighter’s arm around him. I wanted to hug both of them, but I didn’t want to let Sunny go. The firefighter took her when the ambulance crew arrived, and she kept reaching back for my sleeve.
The fire crew went inside after that. I was told to stay by the road. I did, because that was the first sensible thing I’d done all night.
They found Vernon near the kitchen. He’d tried to get to the back door and had fallen. He was taken to the hospital with smoke in his lungs and burns on one hand. The children went with the ambulance too, mostly to be checked. Nobody died.
I keep writing that sentence in my head. Nobody died. It doesn’t make the night less frightening, but it matters.
The fire marshal later said an old space heater and a damaged cord had started the fire. Vernon had been asleep in his chair. He’d tried to put it out himself and then couldn’t get past the smoke. There wasn’t a second hidden cause. There wasn’t a stranger. Just a tired man who’d let too much go wrong in one house.
I saw him three days later at the hospital. The county had placed Abel and Sunny with a woman from their mother’s family while Vernon recovered. I brought a bag with their clothes, which a deputy had asked me to gather from the porch.
Vernon was sitting up in bed. His hand was wrapped. He looked smaller without his boots.
“You called the fire department,” he said.
“I did.”
“Could’ve called sooner.”
I didn’t answer right away. I was mad enough to say something mean, and I knew it. So I said, “Yes. I could have.”
He looked down at his bandage. “I didn’t know the cord was bad.”
“You knew Moses needed water.”
He rubbed his thumb along the blanket. “I thought I could handle things.”
“That wasn’t handling things.”
He didn’t argue. He didn’t apologize either. At least not then.
Moses was taken by the county animal officer. The vet trimmed his hooves and checked him over. I asked if I could adopt him, and I filled out the forms. I had to pay for fencing and a proper shelter. It cost more than I’d planned, but not so much that I could pretend it was the reason to say no.
A week later, Moses came to my place. He walked around the paddock once, stopped by the water trough, and drank. I stood at the gate with my hands in my pockets. I didn’t want to make a fuss over him.
Abel and Sunny visited a few times while their mother arranged her return. I never asked them to tell me about the fire. Sunny would bring Moses a carrot, and Abel would stand by the fence, checking that the latch caught.
“Grandpa said he’s sorry,” Abel told me one afternoon.
I looked at him. “Did he say that to you?”
“Yeah.”
“What did you say?”
“I said okay.”
I knew that answer. I’d said it too, back at the fence with a gun pointed at me. But Abel was a child, and I wasn’t going to tell him what his answer had to mean.
Vernon came to my gate once after he got home. He had a cane and a paper bag with apples in it. He set them down by the post.
“I don’t know if you want these,” he said.
“They’re just apples.”
“I know.”
He didn’t say he was sorry. I didn’t ask him to. He stood there for a minute, and then he went back down the road.
Moses ate the apples later. He ate them carefully, same as the first ones, and I thought about how little it took for me to feel useful. A bucket. A few apples. A reason not to make the call I should have made.
The county closed its case. Vernon got help from his daughter when she came home. The kids weren’t left alone with him again while he healed. I can’t say I know what happened after that in every detail. I know Abel came by last summer. I know Sunny still calls Moses by his name.
When Abel was twelve, he came over with a little wooden sign he’d made in school. He’d painted MOSES in crooked blue letters. I hung it by the gate, though the paint has mostly come off now.
He looked at the old chain, which I’d kept in the shed because I couldn’t bring myself to throw it away.
“Moses came to get you,” he said.
I didn’t tell him that maybe Moses was only frightened and running. I didn’t tell him I still wonder whether he came to my window because he knew I’d follow, or because I was the only person he’d ever seen come back.
I just looked at the broken chain in my hand and said, “Maybe he did.”